Staggered age of consent to be discussed after Brand case, minister says

This is a repost promoting content originally published elsewhere. See more things Dan's reposted.

...

A woman who alleges she was raped by jailed comedian Brand when she was 16 is now campaigning to see the law changed so that relationships between 16 and 17-year-olds and adults would be illegal.

Questions over a staggered age of consent have "been raised and will be discussed" McFadden said, adding: "[I] can't tell you what the conclusion of that would be, but the last week has certainly put that up in lights."

Adults of any age are legally able to have sex with 16 and 17-year-olds, under UK law.

Mia Latter, who has waived her right to anonymity, told the Sunday Times that she wants the age of consent to be staggered.

...

Yes. This.

I'm glad that the idea of a staggered age of consent is finally getting to a point of being seriously discussed. It doesn't fix every power imbalance in sexual relationships - if such a thing is even possible - but such a move could help with the most-serious incidences of grooming and exploitation of young people. In short: I'm happy to see this on the nation's agenda.

That's the important point. But let's talk mathematics for a moment...

Maths and calendars

Legislation like this needs a lot of careful consideration so as not to have unwanted knock-on effects. For example:

If the law says sexual relationships between 16/17-year-olds and adults are illegal:

This is a suggestion proposed in the article, and I've heard it proposed in similar terms many times before. Here's an example of where it falls over -

Alice was born on 17 November 2008. Her boyfriend Bob is a day younger; he was born on 18 November 2008. They've been having consensual sex together for almost two years. But if they have sex today, 17 November 2026, Alice has committed statutory rape. Yesterday was fine; tomorrow was fine; but today's her 18th birthday and so, as an adult, it's forbidden.

That's nonsense, right? But that would be the letter of the law in this scenario. Can we do better?

If the law says sexual relationships between 16/17-year-olds and adults aged 20+ are illegal unless the age difference is no more than three years:

This proposal, from Close The Consent Gap, is much stronger. The "no more than three years" clause solves for cases like Alice and Bob, above. But the same "birthday problem" can show up in wider-age-gap relationships -

Chris was born on 17 November 2006. Their girlfriend Deb was born on 18 November 2009. Yesterday it was legal for them to have sex, because Chris was only 19 years of age. Tomorrow is Deb's 17th birthday, when it will also be legal for them to have sex. But today specifically is Chris's 20th birthday and, with an age gap of three years and one day between them, today alone their sexual relationship is forbidden.

This "allowed, then not allowed, then allowed again" problem can turn up with any regulation on age-gaps that uses full years of age as a measurement. I've picked contrived examples for maximum absurdity, but there are plenty of more-believable possibilities too.

Can we do better?

If the law says sexual relationships between 16/17-year-olds and adults are illegal unless the age difference is no more than three years:

This modification/simplification to Close The Consent Gap's approach solves that problem. Now, it's the age gap that's identified as the problem, rather than the age gap and the age of the older party. The fundamental mathematical issue in all of the above examples is that it uses the numeric ages of two people as the variables, and - unless they share a birthday - the fact that the parties will "step up" out-of-line with one another introduces a problem.1

A problem with this adaptation is that it now criminalises any relationship between Chris and Deb until Deb's 18th birthday. Possibly that could be improved by having a three-year gap if the younger party who's 16 years old and a four-year gap if the younger party is 17 years old. However it's worded, the risk of exploitation - which seems to be most-problematic when the older party is over 21 years old - is reduced by such a staggered approach.2

But while that's probably "good enough", it's still not perfect because...

Leap babies make things confusing

Let's assume the law prohibits a gap of more-than three years between a 16/17-year-old and their older partner:

Eric was born on 29 February 2008. Like all leap babies, he's legally-considered to have reached his "new" age in non-leap years on 1 March, so he turned 18 on 1 March 2026. Frank was born on 1 March 2011. Eric and Frank begin a sexual relationship in March 2027, when Frank is 16 and Eric is 19. It's all totally legal, because they're (exactly) three years apart in age: the absolute limit of the proposed law.

Except 2028 is a leap year. Eric's 20th birthday falls on 29 February 2028, and at that point he's three years and one day older than his 17-year-old boyfriend Frank. Possibly we should consider him to be three years and one day older for the entirety of 2028: the law's not clear on this point! In any case, for at least some of 2028 it's become illegal for Frank and Eric to have sex, even though it was fine in 2027 and will become fine again in 2029.

When you try to legislate with hard-and-fast rules in a world with fuzzy edge cases, like leap years, problems occur.

Pragmatism

Practially-speaking, I'd be very happy to see a law like the one that Close The Consent Gap propose, or my amended version(s) of the same, to come into effect. It's become increasingly apparent that the risk of grooming and sexual exploitation of teenagers by adults - almost always men - in their mid-to-late 20s and above is huge and probably is not offset by individual rights nor mitigated by existing laws.

So yeah, I'm in favour of change here. So long as it's well-written enough that at the very least Alice and Bob don't find themselves unreasonably decriminalised... and ideally Chris and Deb aren't either.

Footnotes

1 This problem already exists in a few other places around the age of consent, but that's just an example of how hard it is to write these laws!

2 Such a model could even be extended further, prohibiting an age gap for 18 or 19-year-olds, but I accept that that introduces different problems about e.g. the legal autonomy and decision-making we assign to adults. Like everything in this area, it's complicated.

0 comments

    Leave a comment

    Reply on your own site