Are you closer to Ireland or Scotland?

I nerdsniped myself today when, during a discussion on the potential location of a taekwondo tournament organised by our local martial arts school, somebody claimed that Scotland would be “nearer” than Ireland.

WhatsApp conversation. Somebody says "Scotland preferred just because nearer/cheaper!", to which Dan replies, with a map showing rulers connecting Witney to the nearest relevant borders, "Certainly cheaper, but (/puts pedantry hat on/) Witney's actually about 40km nearer to Ireland than Scotland. (/takes pedantry hat off and apologises/) (Sorry, sorry, sorry... geography nerd... sorry.)"
I don’t dispute that somebody living near me can get to Scotland faster than Ireland, unless they can drive at motorway speeds across Wales… and the Irish Sea. But the word they used was nearer, and I can be a pedantic arse.

But the question got me thinking:

Could I plot a line across Great Britain, showing which parts are closer to Scotland and which parts are closer to Ireland?

If the England-facing Irish and Scottish borders were completely straight, one could simply extend the borders until they meet, bisect the angle, and we’d be done.

Extremely simplified hand-drawn map of the British Isles, with the (artificially-straight) borders of Scotland and Ireland extended to meet and then their angle bisected to produce a line that splits England by proximity to each country.
Of course, the borders aren’t straight. They also don’t look much like this. I should not draw maps.

In reality, the border between England and Scotland is a winding mess, shaped by 700 years of wars and treaties1. Treating the borders as straight lines is hopelessly naive.

What I’m really looking for… is a Voronoi partition

Animation showing colours gradually expanding from points on a plane, carving out borders along their edges.
Voronoi diagrams are pretty, and cool, and occasionally even useful! This one expands from points, but there’s no reason you can’t expand from a line (line a border!) instead.

My Python skills are pretty shit, but it’s the best tool for the job for geohacking2. And so, through a combination of hacking, tweaking, and crying, I was able to throw together a script that produces a wonderful slightly-wiggly line up the country.

A line cuts from North-West to South-East through England and Wales.
The entire island of Ireland is used here to determine boundaries (you can tell because otherwise parts of County Antrim, in Northern Ireland, would be marked as closer to Scotland than the Republic of Ireland: which they are, of course, but the question was about England!).

Once you’ve bisected England in this way – into parts that are “closer to Ireland” versus parts that are “closer to Scotland”, you start to spot all kinds of interesting things3.

Like: did you know that the entire subterranean part of the Channel Tunnel is closer to Scotland than it is to Ireland… except for the ~2km closest to the UK exit.

Map showing the Le Shuttle terminal and the entrance to the Channel Tunnel, marked up to show how the first 2km of the underground part (only) are closer to Ireland than to Scotland.

A little further North: London’s six international airports are split evenly across the line, with Luton, Stansted and Southend closer to Scotland… and City, Heathrow and Gatwick closer to Ireland.

Map showing the locations of London's six major airports: three North-East of the line, three South-West of it.

The line then pretty-much bisects Milton Keynes, leaving half its population closer to Scotland and half closer to Ireland, before doing the same to Daventry, before – near Sutton Coldfield – it drives right through the middle of the ninth hole of the golf course at the Lea Marston Hotel.

Players tee off closer to Ireland and – unless they really slice it – their ball lands closer to Scotland:

Aerial photograph of a golf course with a red line superimposed across it. Near the green, a speech bubble has a golfer saying "Next shot's going to Scotland!"

In Cannock, it bisects the cemetery, dividing the graves into those on the Scottish half and those in the Irish half:

Aerial photography of Cannock Cemetery, bisected with a thick red line.

The line crosses the Welsh border at the River Dee, East of Wrexham, leaving a narrow sliver of Wales that’s technically closer to Scotland than it is to Ireland, running up the coastline from Connah’s Quay to Prestatyn and going as far inland as Mold before – as is the case in most of Wales – you’re once again closer to Ireland:

Highlighted fragment of Wales along the West bank of the River Dee and stretching about 10-12km inland.
If you live in Flint or Mold, ask your local friends whether they live closer to Ireland or Scotland. The answer’s Scotland, and I’m confident that’ll surprise them.

I’d never have guessed that there were any parts of Wales that were closer to Scotland than they were to Ireland, but the map doesn’t lie4

Anyway: that’s how I got distracted, today. And along the way I learned a lot about geodata encoding, a little about Python, and a couple of surprising things about geography5.

Footnotes

1 Not to mention the crazy history of places like Berwick-upon-Tweed, which has jumped the border several times, and Ba Green, ownership of which has traditionally been decided by game of football.

2 Or, at least: it’s the one that’s most-widely used and so I could find lots of helpful StackOverflow answers when I got stuck!

3 Interesting… if you’re specifically looking for some geographical trivia, that is!

4 Okay, the map lies a little. My program was only simple so it plotted everything on a flat plane, failing to accommodate for Earth’s curvature. The difference is probably marginal, but if you happen to live on or very close to the red line, you might need to do your own research!

5 Like: Chester and Rugby are closer to Scotland than they are to Ireland, and Harpenden and Towcester are closer to Ireland than they are to Scotland! Who knew?

× × × × × × × × ×

0 comments

    Reply here

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Reply on your own site

    Reply elsewhere

    You can reply to this post on Mastodon (@blog@danq.me).

    Reply by email

    I'd love to hear what you think. Send an email to b27553@danq.me; be sure to let me know if you're happy for your comment to appear on the Web!