Meat To Please You

Meat To Please You

There’s something that I just don’t understand about vegetarians. It’s something that I didn’t understand when I mercilessly teased them, and it’s something that I still don’t understand now that I am one:

What’s with the fake meat?

Quorn ‘Roast Chicken Style Slices’. No chickens were harmed in the making of this chicken.

You know the stuff I’m talking about: stuff made out of mycoprotein or TVP or soya that’s specifically designed to emulate real meat in flavour (sometimes effectively) and texture (rarely so). Browse the chilled and frozen aisles of your local supermarket for their “vegetarian” section and you’ll find meatfree (although rarely vegan) alternatives to chicken, turkey, beef and pork, presented here in descending order of how convincing they are as a substitute.

Tesco ‘vegetarian’ hot dogs. There’s actually a distinct possibility that these contain MORE meat than their non-vegetarian counterparts.

Let’s be clear here: it’s not that I don’t see the point in faux meat. It has a few clear benefits: for a start, it makes vegetarianism more-approachable to omnivores who are considering it for the first time. I’ve tried meat substitutes on a number of occasions over the last couple of decades, and they’ve really improved over that time: even a meat-lover like me can be (partially) placated by the selection of substitutes available.

Man, this photo of a BLT looks more delicious every time I use it on my blog. Why do I torture myself this way?

And while I slightly buy-in to the argument that the existence of these fake meats “glorifies” meat-eating, perhaps even to the extent as to under-sell vegetarianism as a poor substitute for the “real thing”, I don’t think that this is in itself the biggest problem with the fake meat industry. There’s a far bigger issue in question:

Why are we stopping here?

A dodo. Apparently it tasted somewhat like turkey, only tougher: there are dozens of accounts of its preparation and consumption.

If we’re really trying here to make “fake meats”, then why are we setting our targets in-line with the commonly-eaten “real meats”? Why stop at chicken and turkey when we might as well make dodo-flavoured nut roasts and Quorn slices? Sure, they’re extinct, so we’ll probably never have real dodo meat: but there’s no reason that the manufacturers of artificial meats can’t have a go. There are dozens of accounts of the preparation and consumption of dodos, so we’d surely be able to emulate their flavour at least as well as we do the meats that we already produce substitutes for.

A tin of unicorn meat: a good source of sparkles! Also cures poison, detects virgins, etc.

Why stop there? We might as well have tins of unicorn meat, too, a meal already familiar to those of us who’ve played more than our fair share of NetHack. How about dragons, or griffins, or the Vegetable Lamb of Tartary? If we’re going to make it up as we go along when we make artificial bacon, we might as well make it up as we go along when we make basilisk-burgers and salamander-sausages, too.

There’s a reason, of course, that we don’t see these more-imaginative meat substitutes. Many of the most loyal fake-meat customers are the kinds of people who don’t like to think about the connection between, for example, “chicken” (the foodstuff), and “chicken” (the clucking bird). To be fair, a lot of meat-eaters don’t like to think about this either, but I get the impression that it’s more-common among vegetarians.

But seriously, though: I think they’re missing a trick, here. Who wouldn’t love to eat artificial pegasus-pâté?

Dan Q is a software engineer, a director of a voluntary organisation, a trainee counsellor, a keen geocacher, and an amateur magician. He lives with his partner and her husband in a polyamorous triad, and occasionally finds time to blog.

14 Comments

  1. I don’t eat much of the stuff, TBH. Interestingly, I find that vegans – or established ones at least – seem to rely less on ‘mock’ products than vegetarians; mist of us don’t consume them in the quantities your average vegetarian uses Quorn.

    • Scatman Dan 5 years ago

      TBF, many of the “fake meats” aren’t vegan-friendly, containing (as they often do) egg as a binding agent.

      • FLB 5 years ago

        Aye, I know. Redwood’s range is all-vegan, though.

  2. Also, dragons and salamanders really exist. </comicbookguy>

    • Scatman Dan 5 years ago

      Not the kind I’m talking about!

      • FLB 5 years ago

        Ahhh, but you didn’t say that! ;p

  3. Quorn chicken filets are pretty good though, tbh. I mostly use fake meat because I dislike cooking with real meat products.

  4. Fake meat is mostly good as a compromise when a vegetarian lives with someone who doesn’t eat vegetables. But I’d be all for some unicorn steaks! And why stop there? Why not have people steaks for those days when you have cannabilistic urges? (we’ve all had those right….?)

  5. The Pacifist 5 years ago

    Could they claim these surreal fake meats tasted authentic? How could they be proved wrong?

    • Claire Q 5 years ago

      “How do the machines know what Tasty Wheat tasted like? Maybe they got it wrong.” – Mouse, The Matrix (1999)

  6. linger 5 years ago

    I’m cool with an eating an imaginary cow, but not an imaginary unicorn…I guess because all unicorns are imaginary.

    • Scatman Dan 5 years ago

      It’s hard to eat a non-imaginary unicorn, it’s true.